Washington has now refunded $86 billion in struck-down tariffs, yet 8,384 approved refunds sit unpaid and small importers may have to sue

black and red ship on body of water at daytime

Thousands of small importers that already won approval for refunds on tariffs struck down by the Supreme Court still have not received a dollar, even as the federal government has disbursed roughly $86 billion to other claimants. Of the 8,384 approved refund claims sitting unpaid, a disproportionate share belong to smaller firms that lack the electronic banking infrastructure the government now requires for disbursement. Senators Ed Markey and Ron Wyden, the ranking Democrats on the Senate Small Business and Finance committees, have warned that these businesses “should not have to sue to recover their own money,” yet litigation may be the only path left for many of them.

Electronic payment rules and the two-tier refund bottleneck

The refund crisis traces back to two colliding federal actions. First, the Supreme Court invalidated tariffs imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act in February 2026, creating an obligation the Bureau of Economic Analysis pegs at roughly $166 billion excluding interest. BEA treats those refunds as capital transfers accrued in the first quarter of 2026 regardless of when cash actually moves. Second, Executive Order 14247, published in the Federal Register on March 25, 2025, shifted federal disbursements from paper checks to electronic ACH payments. Treasury regulations under Title 31 Part 208 enforce that mandate.

The collision of these two actions has produced a measurable gap. Large importers with established ACH accounts and dedicated customs brokers received refunds through existing banking channels almost immediately after approval. Smaller firms, many of which had never set up direct-deposit relationships with the Treasury, hit a wall. Without a valid ACH enrollment, Customs and Border Protection cannot release funds, and the approval simply sits in the queue. CBP has directed importers to its Consolidated Administration and Processing of Entries system for IEEPA refund processing, with CSMS message 68340863 announcing a CAPE deployment date of April 20, 2026. The Court of International Trade posted its own notice pointing importers to that CBP guidance. But for firms that have never interacted with CAPE or lack the technical staff to complete enrollment, the system creates a practical barrier that large corporations do not face.

Trade lawyers describe a de facto two-tier system. Well-resourced multinationals simply updated their ACH instructions and watched refunds arrive, often within days of CBP approval. By contrast, small family-owned importers report weeks of unanswered help-desk tickets as they try to navigate identity checks, bank verification, and CAPE user registration. Several industry associations say their members have received conflicting instructions about whether outdated paper check information on file can be used as a fallback, deepening confusion.

Senate pressure and the $80 billion gap in disbursements

The gap between what the government owes and what it has paid is stark. BEA data shows $166 billion in total obligations, while roughly $86 billion has gone out the door, leaving about $80 billion outstanding. Ranking Members Markey and Wyden have called for automatic processing of all approved refunds without requiring small firms to file individual lawsuits at the Court of International Trade. Their joint statement frames the delay as a policy choice, not a technical limitation, arguing that Treasury and CBP already have the entry data and duty payment records needed to validate claims and push out funds.

The senators’ warning comes against a broader backdrop of concern in Congress about the impact of trade policy on smaller firms. In a separate statement, Senate Democrats led by Chuck Schumer highlighted how the previous administration’s tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act and other authorities had contributed to higher costs for small businesses and manufacturers. Lawmakers now argue that failing to promptly return illegally collected duties compounds that harm by tying up working capital that firms need for payroll, inventory, and credit lines.

Markey and Wyden have pressed Treasury to create an interim pathway for businesses unable to clear the ACH hurdle, such as one-time paper checks or a simplified enrollment portal tailored to low-volume importers. They also want CBP to publish disaggregated statistics on unpaid approvals by firm size, industry, and claim age, which could clarify whether small businesses are indeed bearing the brunt of the backlog. So far, agencies have released only aggregate figures, making it hard to verify anecdotal reports from trade groups.

In the absence of administrative fixes, attorneys expect a wave of so-called test cases at the Court of International Trade. Individual importers can sue for specific refunds, but coordinated litigation could challenge the electronic-payment requirement itself as an unreasonable barrier where liability is undisputed and approvals already issued. Some legal scholars suggest that if judges view the ACH mandate as effectively nullifying the Supreme Court’s ruling for a subset of claimants, they may order CBP to devise alternative payment methods.

Small businesses weigh legal action

For now, many small importers are caught between financial strain and the cost of hiring counsel. A single IEEPA refund might total only tens of thousands of dollars, making full-blown litigation uneconomical unless firms band together or secure contingency arrangements. Trade associations are exploring pooled representation and template filings to lower costs, but those efforts remain in early stages.

Meanwhile, accountants warn that BEA’s treatment of the refunds as first-quarter 2026 capital transfers could create mismatches between financial statements and bank balances. Companies may show a large receivable and improved equity on paper while still scrambling to cover immediate expenses because the cash has not arrived. For thinly capitalized importers, that disconnect can spook lenders and suppliers who do not follow the technical details of national accounts.

With tens of billions of dollars still in limbo, the stakes extend beyond individual firms. If the backlog persists, it could undercut confidence in the government’s ability to unwind unlawful trade measures in an orderly way. For small importers that survived years of elevated tariffs, the prospect of having to sue to recover money the government already agrees it owes is more than a bureaucratic headache; it is a test of whether the promise of relief after the Supreme Court’s decision will be realized in practice or remain stuck behind an electronic gateway they cannot easily pass.


Free tool for readers: Curious where your retirement stands on a 0–100 scale? You can get your free Retirement Safety Score in about five minutes — no account, no bank details, just your number and a few steps to improve it.