About $1 billion in improper Supplemental Security Income payments went to 333,800 recipients because Social Security staff did not work earnings alerts, according to an audit released Sept. 23, 2026 by the agency’s Office of the Inspector General. Roughly $344 million of that estimate is still recoverable, the office said.
The totals are projections from a sample, not a ledger of bills. Auditors found 417,291 SSI recipients with at least one pending earnings alert and reviewed 100 of those cases. They estimated the improper payments from what the 100 showed.
An earnings alert is a flag that wages on file for a recipient differ from the amount used to figure the payment. SSI is paid to older, blind and disabled people with little income, and the amount generally falls as income rises. The inspector general’s news release on the audit says employees resolved the alerts correctly for 20 of the 100 recipients. The other 80 had alerts left unresolved, or cleared without fully checking wage information.
Retirement deadlines, in your inbox: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our SSI & Disability Income Checkup as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the SSI checkup →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
Alerts that sat for two years
For 63 of the sampled recipients, required reviews were never started or finished. Those alerts had been pending for an average of 733 days. For another 17, employees cleared the alert without recording all of the earnings that should have counted.
Michelle L. Anderson, the Assistant Inspector General for Audit, serving as First Assistant, said the agency “has the opportunity to strengthen its controls to ensure employees timely and accurately resolve earnings alerts.” She added that timely and thorough resolution can also help Social Security recover overpayments.
Why $664 million of it is hard to collect
Not all of the money can be pursued. The inspector general said Social Security cannot recover an estimated $664 million under its administrative finality rules unless fraud or similar fault is established. That leaves approximately $344 million that remains recoverable.
The $344 million is an estimate of what could still be collected, not money the agency has taken back. The release does not say how or when any collection would happen, and it does not say whether letters will go out to the recipients in the sample or to the wider group.
What a recipient would see if a bill follows
An overpayment is announced by notice, and the clock starts on the notice date. Social Security says on its overpayment page that it withholds 10% of an SSI payment each month if the money is not repaid within 30 days, and that a waiver or appeal filed in that window stops collection until the agency decides.
A recipient who reported wages on time and still gets a bill is in a different spot from one who never reported them. The administrative finality rule the auditors cited points to why: the agency’s ability to collect depends on how the overpayment arose.
The agency’s response so far
The inspector general made three recommendations. They call for correcting the 63 alerts never worked, correcting the 17 where earnings were not fully recorded, and finding out why employees do not pursue or resolve alerts accurately. Social Security agreed to carry them out.
In a July announcement, the agency said it is expanding use of its Access to Financial Institution tool to catch improper payments early and avoid large overpayments. The program covers more than seven million people, according to the same release.
Keeping earnings reports in order
SSI recipients who work, or whose household income changes, report the change to the agency, and keep a copy of what was sent and when. The SSI program page is the official starting point for reporting rules and limits.
An alert that goes unworked does not erase the reported wages. A recipient who keeps dated records of what was reported can show the agency the timeline if a notice arrives later.
Reported wages to SSI and never heard back?
A note of the date, the amount and who received it is the first thing to find if a notice ever arrives.
The audit shows an alert can sit for years and still end in a bill. A recipient whose wages were reported, or were not, may only learn which when a notice lands with a 30-day clock on it.
The SSI & Disability Action Kit lays out the 2026 SSI income and resource limits, the review and reporting steps, and an income and resource organizer for logging each earnings report. Part 5 covers reviews, reporting and overpayments.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
David M. Keller is a finance writer based in Columbus, Ohio, covering personal finance and consumer-focused economic topics. He earned his degree in journalism from Ohio University and began his career reporting on local business and economic trends for a regional media outlet. Since then, he has contributed to a variety of online publications, focusing on clear, practical coverage of topics such as cost of living, debt, and everyday financial decision-making.
